Milo Ventimiglia has trouble naming three Mandy Moore songs on WWHL
By Reed Gaudens
Can Milo Ventimiglia name three of his This Is Us co-star Mandy Moore’s songs? Andy Cohen put him to the test on the latest Watch What Happens Live!
Happy birthday, Mandy Moore? As the singer-actress celebrates her 34th birthday, she learned that her on-screen husband doesn’t know her music very well. (Seeing as the star once refunded a fan’s money for her first album, she surely doesn’t mind.) Milo Ventimiglia dropped by Bravo’s Watch What Happens Live where host Andy Cohen asked the hard questions.
During the show’s infamous Plead the Fifth segment, in which stars are forced to answer tough questions but bow out of one, Cohen asked Milo Ventimiglia to name three Mandy Moore songs. Having already plead the fifth on a question about Gilmore Girls jumping the shark (wise choice), the man otherwise known as Jack gave it his best effort.
Watch your favorite shows on fuboTV: Watch over 67 live sports and entertainment channels with a 7-day FREE trial!
Of course, Ventimiglia was able to name Moore’s debut hit “Candy” right off the bat (though he did incorrectly identify it as her album title, but we won’t split hairs). He also named the underrated bop “Crush,” but he fell short of naming a third Mandy Moore song. Come on! “Walk Me Home.” “I Wanna Be with You.” “In My Pocket.” “Cry.” Don’t worry, we’ll make you a playlist, Milo!
Watch Milo Ventimiglia plead the fifth in the video below!
Elsewhere during Ventimiglia’s appearance on WWHL alongside The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story stars Ricky Martin and Darren Criss, he and Martin participated in an enlightening game of “Dish in the Dark,” and you’ll be blushing by the second question. During the after show, a This Is Us fan asked Ventimiglia for any Season 3 spoilers, but you’ll just have to watch what happened to get the scoop. (Hint: We’ve provided the same “spoiler.”)
Watch more of Milo Ventimiglia’s revealing appearance on Watch What Happens Live in the video below!
Next: 13 classic Mandy Moore songs you need to listen to right now
Can YOU name three Mandy Moore songs? What did you think of Milo Ventimiglia’s Watch What Happens Live appearance? Let us know your answers in the comments, and be sure to keep the conversation going over on Twitter at @thisisuscrying!
This Is Us returns for Season 3 in September on NBC.